LiqueurMediumMason jar

Cocktail guide

Oatmeal Cookie

Name: Oatmeal Cookie
Cuisine: Cocktail
Ingredients: 2 parts Kahlua; 2 parts Baileys Irish Cream; 4 parts Butterscotch Schnapps; 1 part Jagermeister; 1/2 part Goldschlager

Oatmeal Cookie combines Kahlua, Baileys Irish Cream, Butterscotch Schnapps, Jagermeister in a cocktail served in a mason jar. It is a strong fit for after dinner, date night and feels right at home in a well-stocked cocktail rotation.

Taste profile

Balanced, balanced, soft, and smooth.

Best for

Best for after dinner, date night.

Quick fact

Oatmeal Cookie is usually served as a cocktail in a mason jar, and its identity is shaped by Kahlua, Baileys Irish Cream, Butterscotch Schnapps.

4.0 from 13 ratings

Rate it if you tried it

WhatsApp X Facebook

Ingredients

Everything in the glass.

5 total

Kahluaspirit - Alcoholic

2 parts

Baileys Irish Creamspirit - Alcoholic

2 parts

Butterscotch Schnappsspirit - Alcoholic

4 parts

Jagermeisteringredient - Non-alcoholic

1 part

Goldschlageringredient - Non-alcoholic

1/2 part

How to make it

Build it step by step.

3 steps

1Just mix it all together.
2It's meant to be a shot, but it works just fine as a proper adult-sized drink over lots of ice.
3Tastes like an oatmeal cookie.

Method

Mixed

Finish

No garnish note saved yet.

After Dinner Date Night More Liqueur cocktails

Taste map

Strength

Balanced

Sweetness

Balanced

Sourness

Soft

Bitterness

Smooth

Read: Oatmeal Cookie is a medium alcoholic cocktail for after dinner with Kahlua, Baileys Irish Cream, Butterscotch Schnapps.

Texture and serve cues

-Has citrus

-Has bubbles

✓Creamy texture

-Frozen style

Best for

Best for after dinner, date night.

Glassware

Mason jar

More to know before you make it

A fuller read on the drink.

Flavor read

Expect a balanced profile with support from Kahlua, Baileys Irish Cream, Butterscotch Schnapps.

Best pairing

Easy to serve with snacks, small plates, and casual sharing food.

Serving style

Serve in a mason jar and aim for a medium prep that still feels polished in the glass.

Where it fits

Oatmeal Cookie sits comfortably in the liqueur cocktail tradition, with an approachable style for home bartenders.

Background

Why this cocktail keeps showing up.

Oatmeal Cookie is usually served as a cocktail in a mason jar, and its identity is shaped by Kahlua, Baileys Irish Cream, Butterscotch Schnapps.

Reference cards

Base spirit

Liqueur

More cocktails in the liqueur lane.

4.0

Liqueur

ABC

ABC is a easy alcoholic cocktail for after dinner with Amaretto, Baileys Irish Cream, Cognac.

EasyStrongBalanced

3.9

Liqueur

Americano

Americano is a medium alcoholic cocktail for house party with Campari, Sweet Vermouth, Lemon Peel.

MediumBalancedLight

4.1

Liqueur

Applecar

Applecar is a easy alcoholic cocktail for house party with Applejack, Triple Sec, Lemon Juice.

EasyStrongLight

If you like this one

More cocktails with similar ingredients.

4.1

Liqueur

Quick F**K

Quick F**K is a easy alcoholic cocktail for after dinner with Kahlua, Midori Melon Liqueur, Baileys Irish Cream.

EasyStrongBalanced

3.9

Vodka

Oreo Mudslide

Oreo Mudslide is a medium alcoholic cocktail for after dinner with Vodka, Kahlua, Baileys Irish Cream.

MediumBalancedBalanced

4.0

Liqueur

Dirty Nipple

Dirty Nipple is a easy alcoholic cocktail for after dinner with Kahlua, Sambuca, Baileys Irish Cream.

EasyStrongBalanced

Pour by bottle

Let the bottle call the direction and keep the list tight.

When the base spirit is already settled, these are the faster, cleaner entry points. Think of them as three distinct house styles instead of one crowded shelf.